Longtime Colts Starter Emerging As Trade Candidate
According to The Athletic's Jonathan Jones, he's also a name to keep an eye on before the November 10 trade deadline.
Jones put Stewart on a list of six players he's tracking after talking to sources around the league this week.
The others are Steelers pass rusher Alex Highsmith, Commanders tackle Daron Payne, Giants edge rusher Kayvon Thibodeaux, Browns receiver Jerry Jeudy, and Jaguars receiver Brian Thomas Jr.
Jones kept the framing simple. "For now, it's quiet," he wrote.
Nothing in his reporting says Indianapolis is shopping Stewart.
An Expiring Deal And A Decision Coming Either Way
Stewart is 32, turns 33 on October 20, and is playing out the last year of the three-year, $39 million contract he signed in March 2024.
He's carrying a $14.25 million cap hit this season on an $11.74 million base salary.
Per Spotrac, a trade would clear $12.25 million of that and leave $2 million in dead money behind.
That math is a big part of why his name keeps coming up.
Early trade deadline candidates to keep an eye on, per @jjones9: Marvin Harrison Jr. Brian Thomas Jr. Jerry Jeudy Kayvon Thibodeaux Alex Highsmith Daron Payne Grover Stewart https://t.co/ZS0b63IXZa
— Underdog NFL (@UnderdogNFL) October 3, 2026
He's in the same spot as Payne, who's also playing out an expiring contract on Jones' list.
Spotrac flagged Stewart as one of the league's top cut candidates earlier this year, though SI's Colts site argued there was almost no chance Indianapolis would go that route.
The Colts took him in the fourth round in 2017, 144th overall, in Chris Ballard's first draft as general manager.
This is his 10th season with the team, and he has 12 total tackles, 0.5 sacks, and a pass defended across four games this year.
The Market Hasn't Opened Yet
Jones' read on the league is that nobody's out of the playoff picture yet, so nobody's parting with players who can help them win right now.
The deadline is still more than five weeks away.
But, whether Ballard would listen on Stewart depends on where the Colts stand when November arrives.
His age works against him on the open market, too.
The Athletic’s Johnathan Jones listed Steelers OLB Alex Highsmith as a possible trade candidate at the deadline: “After shaking down sources this week, I’m keeping an eye on a number of players: Steelers OLB Alex Highsmith, Commanders DT Daron Payne, Colts DT Grover Stewart, Giants OLB Kayvon Thibodeaux, Browns WR Jerry Jeudy and Jaguars WR Brian Thomas Jr. For now, it’s quiet.” 👀 #Steelers #NFL
— Blitzburgh (@Blitz_Burgh) October 3, 2026
His trade value has been pegged earlier this year at Day 3 draft capital, with word that Indianapolis would be fortunate to land a fifth-round pick or better.
Whatever happens before the deadline, he's headed for free agency in the spring.